Our Belgian Minister for Equality recently suggested that job applications should be made anonymous. She’s convinced that the exchange of only the relevant facts and nothing else will discourage discrimination in a working environment and will lead to a more correct hiring procedure. My immediate thought is: when will be the right time for the candidate to reveal his or her identity? That moment cannot be postponed endlessly, can it? I can almost see it happen: “Dear colleagues, here is our new project manager. Tara!” And up goes the curtain.
Of course that’s not what is meant, this example is really to the extreme. But still you have to question which elements are considered to be personal? Name? Address? Gender? Hobbies? Interests? Former work experience even? In the 70’s it was common practice to send a photo along with ones candidature. I can understand how this could be misused. But on the other hand, are we not overestimating anonymity, and at the same time underestimating the value of what makes us all unique individuals? Your CV and application is supposed to highlight your differentiating factor, your USP, and in some people it’s the person that makes them individuals.
Why for example do some people make their phone calls anonymously? Do they fear that they will be pushed off? If so, why bother making the call? It’s not going to be a great conversation anyway, is it? I never answer anonymous calls, sorry but I’m not going to talk to a shadow. If the caller has no problem telling me who he or she is on the phone call, then why not start with that? In real life, you would never stand awkwardly with no introduction. You start by saying “Hello, I’m so and so, do you have minute …” it sounds perfectly reasonable to me.
And suppose we do stick to only relevant facts when it comes to applications, will we then be sure to get the right picture? Last week I thought I might as well join a professional PR group on one of the social networks. My application was declined. Apparently I did not meet the membership standards. I dare to question that, you’ll understand. Either their automatic (?) verification system missed it or they hold very peculiar standards… that was with all my information, imagine if they only had the relevant.








